For Alligator’s birthday party, I made a cookie of each child with their initial on it to take home.
I used refrigerated dough.
Then once baked, I made a glaze of confectioner’s sugar and a little bit of milk. I dipped the cookie in the glaze and let dry. Then wrote their initial on the cookie with blue icing. I allowed it to harden and then wrapped it up.
I also gave each child a Elmo Alphabet workbook.
This is how I displayed them. I put them by the door, so that I wouldn’t forget to hand them out. I am notorious for doing that.